1. Trista lied to Nancy Grace regarding her whereabouts. She lied more so by omission, but her saying she was at the Maine Motel the night Ayla went missing is not being completely honest. It leaves out important details that were later released.
2. Carol Bengle Gilbert originally said that Trista and Robert Fortier drove back to Portland and then to Waterville. Now the story is that they drove directly to Waterville.
3. Trista still has not completed a lie detector test. People are comfortable with assuming that Justin failed, but they don't question the fact that Trista still has not taken one. Neither has Becca. Or Jessica. Or Jeff. Or Ronald. From what we know, the only person on that side to have even taken the polygraph successfully is Ronnie. We KNOW that all 3 people who were in the home have completed polygraphs.
4. Police have not ruled Trista out as a suspect.
5. Trista's blood was supposedly found in the Waterville home. She has never cleared up how much blood was hers or how much was Ayla's. If more than a cupful total was found, wouldn't Trista revealing that at least some of it was hers change that amount?
6. Trista completely lied on investigators by saying they had not contacted her before the May 31 press conference.
7. The Reynolds family allowed cameras to record their reaction to that press conference and it seemed rehearsed. Why allow the filming first of all, and why have such a choreographed response?
8. Trista will not reveal how much child support Justin was ordered to pay. This is important, because many of you have speculated that he killed Ayla to get out of paying child support. What if the amount he was ordered to pay was $20 a month? It's funny that those of you who use the child support motive for murder are the same people who say Justin was unemployed. Unemployed people, especially STUDENTS, are not going to be ordered to pay thousands in support.
9. Trista lied to the media initially about why Ayla was not in her care. To this day, no one knows for sure if it was an agreement, if Ayla was placed with the DiPietros, or if "DHHS violate Trista's rights."
10. Trista initially said she was in rehab for alcohol abuse, and she had people from her family as well as Amanda Benner repeat that lie. She later came out and admitted to being a
11. No charges have been pressed on anyone, and the last I heard, McCausland said talk of that is premature.
12. Trista admitted to being bipolar and off her meds. She further admitted to taking care of Ayla and Raymond while drunk. We can now assume she took care of them when she was on drugs as well, because that is what she went to rehab for. People are still adamant that Trista was a great mother, cared about Ayla, and gave her a good life before the DiPietros stepped in. I will say this again: DRUG ADDICTS CANNOT BE GOOD PARENTS. Drugs make people forget that they have children.
13. The last few "awareness" events have featured Ayla, but they have really been about raising money for Cynthia Caron. Her name was basically used for publicity.** This is more my opinion than a sensitive topic, but I felt like putting it, so I did.**
14. Trista has yet to prove any abuse happened to Ayla at the hands of Justin. She can provide no proof of phone calls to DHHS, no photos, nothing. The only "proof" she provided was a doctor's report, but in that report she admits to bringing Ayla to the doctor several days after the injury occurred. I'm more apt to believe that Trista caused the injury while high or drunk and then blamed "part time daddy". My opinion. She claims to have pictures of the ball pit bruises. Where are they?
15. Trista has lied throughout the course of this case NUMEROUS times. "Innocent parents of missing children do not lie." I'm quoting Peeter Hyatt on that one.
16. Jeff said that Trista is incapable of lying.
What have I left off? What have I included unfairly? I'm sure someone will let me know!
love! Nice job Obscure. ~yb
ReplyDeleteAdding to my list of favorite posts.
ReplyDeleteAnd dont forget her interview with the very early comment on how "Justin was the last to see Ayla ALIVE". That has always bothered me...it was long before any LE spoke of a deceased Ayla.
ReplyDeleteKeep trying Obscure. . . lol This is just too funny.
ReplyDelete1. Pheobe blatently lied in her interview
ReplyDelete2. Carol Bengle Gilbert is not Trista so its hearsay, not out of Trista's mouth
3. If LE thought it was necessary for Trista to take another Poly she would be. . .I would say that this in itself says a lot as to which way this case will be going
4. They haven't said the negative things about Trista that they have said about the Waterville 3. . . I have never heard any comment from LE pointing to Trista being deceiptful or not sharing all that she knows
5. As you have said many times Obscure, "JUSTINE OWES NO ONE ANY ANSWERS. . .I guess that should go with Trista also, she has been more than forthcoming
6. Big deal the important thing is what came out in the Conference, LE Believes that Ayla is no longer with us, Poor baby Ayla
7. They filmed it to show whoever hurt Ayla that she was very loved
8. As I stated above, Trista owes you no answers
9. I would ask that you check your facts on this one, it was stated from the beginning that she was going to Rehab to deal with a problem she had and that she asked Justin to take care of Ayla while she was in Rehab, when she got out of Rehab Ayla was to be returned. . .. unfortunately that never happened and now we no longer have Ayla
10. Again you need to check you "FACTS" on this one, because we can only go with facts on this blog remember????
11. Charges will be brought, LE has to make sure when they go after Justin they have all their ducks in a row in order to make sure he goes away forever
12. Again, show us the facts on this. . and yes Trista was a great mother and loved her child very, very much. . .Justin on the otherhand lost her while he was supposed to be protecting her
13. Really, your opinin means nothing, show us the facts please
14. I think the doctors report is pretty good proof what more do you need
15. It is again your opinion that Trista lied, your opinion is not important
16. Im sure Jeff knows Trista well
Lmao. Thank you for reacting exactly how your cult expects you to. You guys demand answers from Justin, but Trista (who is a suspect as well) owes no one anything.
DeleteI just have to say in response to your #12- "Justin on the otherhand lost her while he was supposed to be protecting her". That's one of the most absurd things I've ever heard. A child going missing is not necessarily the fault of the parent. Was it the Klaas' fault when Polly went missing? Or Elizabeth Smart's families fault? Being a parent means protecting your children, yes. But parents are by no means perfect. As much as we want to, we cannot possibly watch our children every second of every day. In an ideal world, we wouldn't have to worry about anything bad ever happening to our children, but that's not the case. Unfortunately, we can't sleep with them by our sides forever, or watch their every move. If there are parents out there who have not "lost" their child for even a second, hats off to you. I'm not saying every child will go missing because of another person, but most kids pull disappearing acts. Hiding under the clothes racks at the store. Hiding in the closet. Sneaking outside while parents are sleeping or in the bathroom. There's tons of ways kids are "lost". That doesn't mean a parent doesn't love their child and isn't protecting them. It means they're human.
DeleteIn response to Anonymous 9:22
Delete1. Phoebe did not "blatantly" lie.
2. Carol Bengle Gilbert was in communication with Jeff or Ron through emails supposedly.
3. Polygraphs were ALL done voluntarily.
4. LE has not said anyone has been deceitful.
5. Trista has not been forthcoming. She has just had to admit to everything she has been called out on because she really had no choice because she was caught redhanded.
6. What came out in the conference that you think is so important? That LE thinks Ayla will most likely not be found alive? That is what is important to you?
7. This is how they choose to show their love??
8. Redundant
9. Who should Obscure check these facts with? Trista? Because all we have to go by on this story is Trista's word and the thing is I don't know if you've noticed but her word changes from day to day.
10. Not going to research it right now but pretty sure the facts originated from a post Trista herself made. If someone finds it can you please copy and paste it here. Thanks. But otherwise feel free to ask any of her "past" friends
11. You have been saying that for a year now. What evidence has taken them a year to gather?
12. She may love her children in her own warped way. But she is not a great mother. A great mother is not selfish. Trista is selfish. She met her own needs over children's. And parent's whose children are kidnapped don't lose them. They are stolen from them. And hopefully nothing bad ever happens to one of your children now. Because I would not want you to have to look in the mirror and have to blame yourself for not protecting them.
13. Obscure's opinion obviously means something or you wouldn't be here. And only you choose to not see the facts.
14. The doctors report stated only that the mother was concerned of abuse. It did not state the doctor was concerned. Furthermore the doctor did NOT report abuse. And as Obscure points out Trista was in fact taking care of Ayla at the time and waited a several days after she says the injury occurred before taking Ayla to the doctors. So who's to say when it actually happened.
15. Again redundant
16. Creepy
What do you mean, Im just discussing your blog post and thats all you have to say. . . not going to say Im suprised. . . why don't you try real hard to come back with something a little more intellent then blaming it on a cult blog. . lol Why do I have to be associated with any blog. . .are you saying if I think Justin is guilty because of what has and has not been said I belong to a cult???? Can you say hypocrite??? Im disappointed, I was expecting a better response. . . I would call my answer a sensitive subject LOLOLOLOLOL And furthermore, at Least Trista has been forthcoming with information which we cannot say for Justina!
DeletePlease refer to #5 in above post.
DeletePlease tell me one thing that Trista was forthcoming about that she admitted to BEFORE it was already splashed all over the blogs or news.
Her blood in Justin's bedroom.
Delete@Grace you're right, but you could be wrong. It could very well be that the blood initially discovered was hers. In that case, it was still splashed all over the news before she released it.
Delete"What have I included unfairly?"
ReplyDeleteIMO, nothing.
you've left off that Trista has gone stone cold silent since her last meeting with detectives. A first since her daughter has gone missing.
ReplyDelete1.
ReplyDelete+***Such as what? Seriously, I'm not sure what you're referring to. MSP stated they know where she was that night.
2.
***CBG is a Yahoo contributor who writes OpEd pieces, not hard news. Any other source?
3.
***I don't like the fact that Trista wasn't able to complete a LDT. I don't like that investigators supposedly said it was good enough. Everyone in the immediate family and those present in the house should all be tested.
4.
***No one has been publicly ruled out, although privately I'm sure investigators have their suspicions.
5.
***Not necessarily. It hasn't been confirmed how much was found. She could, in general terms, probably say how much was hers but how would Trista know how much was Ayla's?
6.
***Agreed
7.
***Agreed, although I don't know that it was choreographed.
8.
***I don't think Ayla's disappearance had anything to do with Child Support. What he was paying was probably a minimal amount. The amount was redacted from the document. They may have been advised to do that.
9.
***Agreed - all too confusing.
10.
***People still repeat the alcohol rehab. It was drugs (maybe both).
11.
***No argument there.
12.
***In complete agreement
13.
***Lost & Missing is a legitimate organization. If they keep awareness on Ayla with their events while raising money for LNM to help other families, I see no problem in that.
14.
***Another confusing situation, like the DHHS one.
15.
***You're taking what he says out of context. Innocent parents of missing children do not lie about the important things - like if they know where their children are, the circumstances surrounding the disappearance. Innocent parents will lie about things they feel guilty about, like if they weren't watching them closely, or if they had a fight with them before they disappeared.
16.
***NO ONE is incapable of lying.
OT, but has anyone seen the age-progression photos and if so, are they really that off-base? Curious about this as she is very adamant and seems angry and added "and there will be issues" if they do not comply with her demands.
ReplyDeleteJohn P says:
February 6, 2013 at 2:59 pm
OT, This is a very important message to all that have considered posting the “age progression” fliers in your area.
Dear All: Somewhere floating around is an “age progression” photo of baby Ayla Reynolds that someone made. This message is from her mother and we ask if anyone finds AGED PHOTOS done by folks online to please delete them and let those sharing or whomever is making them to please stop. This is Trista Reynolds message today, Feb. 6, 2013 to Cynthia Caron of LostNMissing Inc:
Hi Cynthia, I do not like it and I am not okay with it. Cynthia I know my daughter and Ayla would not look like that. I do not want that poster up anywhere if it goes there will be an issues so please tell them to please not post it AT ALL!!!!!! In respect please thank you. Trista Reynolds, Ayla’s mom
I haven't seen the age progressed photo, but would love to.
DeleteI'm not sure how I feel about this without knowing more.
Wouldn't and shouldn't the father also have a say in this?
Ayla's dad is putting out flyers and I'm pretty sure he does not need Trista's permission to do his own age progression photos. So this might send a confusing message to the public.
Delete"You don't give a rat's ass who is lying"
ReplyDeleteSeriously? So it is okay by you if Justin say were lying? LE has not once said Justin was lying. Only that they "believe" someone in the home knows more.
Knowing more could mean many things.
Trista on the other hand has proven herself in this case to be a known liar. So what else DON'T we know that Trista has lied about. I don't know about Obscure but yeah that bothers me.