12.29.2012

Thin Line: Love/Hate

As we all know, detectives met with the DiPietro family in October; the discussion was frank, and McCausland views it as positive. 

FYIfrank-/fraNGk/Adjective. Open, honest, and direct in speech or writing, esp. when dealing with unpalatable matters.

Somehow, members of a certain cult blog have found a way to spin the nature of the meeting with the DiPietros. At the same time, those people have not managed to find a way to explain the apparent lack of communication between Trista and law enforcement. Why isn't U4A up in arms about this? There must be someone they can send a petition to?!

Anyway, I took a look back at some of the things she has said regarding police, and I found a few statements of interest----

12/23/11-"Everything I'm hearing I'm hearing from news reporters," Trista Reynolds said. "I'm just like everybody else out there right now. I'm not hearing from any detectives, any state police, nothing — just what I hear on the news."

02/15/12-Trista Reynolds said that although police haven’t confirmed it, she is not a suspect. She said part of the reason for that is that police have told her things about the investigation.

05/18/12-Trista Reynolds said it's rare that she gets updates from police these days, but she continues to hope that there will be a tip that helps police crack the case.

05/20/12-Earlier this month, Reynolds was told that investigators planned to show her photographs of those items, but that hasn't happened yet, she said. "I don't know when I will be seeing what was found," she said. Reynolds said she felt mixed emotions upon learning that some items are not related to the case."I'm irritated, angry, frustrated and sad," she said. Reynolds said her frustrations also extend toward state police. "I think they could be doing a lot more than what they're doing," she said. McCausland said Friday that he understands Reynolds' frustration and the frustrations of other people who have been following the case for five months.

06/01/12-While McCausland said he talked to Trista Reyolds before the press conference, in an interview with reporters after the news conference, she said she had not heard from police, that she had been in appointments and had not been near a telephone early Thursday.

12/13/12-
...Ayla's mother Trista Reynolds said the silence from police has become disquieting. Reynolds said she used to receive regular updates from state police detectives, but hasn't heard anything lately. "They don't call me," she said. "The only time I hear from them is if I call them and leave them a message. The detective that I work with will call me, but they don't freely call me like they used to."

12/28/12-Reynolds said a meeting scheduled for Dec. 19 was canceled by a detective who told her it would be rescheduled later that week. "I still haven't heard from them," Reynolds said Thursday. Investigators were planning to show Reynolds items that were recovered from the Kennebec River during a search of the Lockwood Dam on April 25, she said. They also planned to present her the same information that investigators shared with members of Ayla's paternal family -- father Justin DiPietro, aunt Elisha DiPietro and grandmother Phoebe DiPietro -- in October, Reynolds said. "They've been doing this for six months," she said of the delays. "Six months ago, when all this stuff came up in the river, they told me they wanted to sit down and show things to me, and they still haven't done it. Now they're playing games with me."

12/29/12-After complaining Maine State Police cancelled a schedule meeting on the case of her missing daughter Ayla, Trista Reynolds told the Morning Sentinel the meeting has been rescheduled. Ayla Reynolds has been missing for more than a year. Trista Reynolds said this week the cancelled meeting would have focused on reviewing materials found during the search. She said police contacted her Friday to reschedule the appointment for next week.
Is it just me, or does it seem like Trista displays a concerning pattern of passive-aggression? She says horrible things about Justin in the media, and then wonders why he won't talk to her. She has essentially done the same thing to law enforcement. It's okay for her to be frustrated with the lack of progress in the case, but to say investigators aren't doing enough? To lie on investigators? What the hell is this woman's problem? To publicly say these things about the only people who can bring your daughter back to you baffles me. Next thing you know, she'll be threatening to sue them.

Trista may have hit the nail on the head. She said part of the reason she was not a suspect is because they told her things about the investigation. Now that they are not telling her anything, not showing her photos as promised, and cancelling/rescheduling meetings, can we safely assume that she is now a suspect? Hmm...

By the way, the fact that members of the paternal family have already been told the information that they keep withholding from Trista is intriguing. Are they not telling Trista because it implicates her? Because she might run her big mouth to the media and jeopardize the case? Or some other unknown reason? Your guess is as good as mine, but the whole thing is interesting. 

31 comments:

  1. One quote you won't see over at the death blog...

    "It brought hope back to this family that the police were working for them and not against them,"

    The DiPietro's viewed the meeting as positive.
    MSP viewed the meeting as positive.
    IMO, this was the most important item in the article.
    It suggest that MSP are looking at other things/people, othetr than the DiPietro's.

    It is VERY interestng that MSP talk to and share evidence with the DiPitero's long before Trista.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It sure is VERY interesting. LE shared evidence with the DiPietros way back in October, but for some reason they are keeping Trista out of the loop.

      It is clear that communications between the DiPietros and LE have improved. I should think Trista would be overjoyed by this reversal in attitude, but she comes off as being annoyed and frustrated.

      Delete
    2. S., Are you serious?

      It is positive for MSP because anytime communication breaks down with the family of a victim, they potentially lose access to valuable investigative info- whether the family is in the suspect category or not- and may suffer negative public perceptions and have more challenges to deal with that add work without benefiting the case.

      Delete
    3. the space between12/29/12, 8:07 PM

      I find it curious there was no mention of meeting with "the 3" - that it was Justin, Elisha, and Phoebe instead of Courtney.

      Delete
    4. It is clear that communication between the dipietros and LE has improved? One meeting? I hope that continues.
      Trista complains when she feels she does not hear enough from LE. At least that shows she cares. have the dipietros been complaining?
      What info did they share with the dipietros that day that they did not share with trista allready? Any specifics that anyone knows of? I was'nt there to hear it.

      Delete
    5. Yes, I am serious, ..and I do not disagree with your comment at all. I understand why MSP views the renewed communcation as positive.

      What I feel is important and revealing is the fact that the DiPietro family found the meeting in Oct.(or Nov) with MSP, as positive.

      "It brought hope back to this family that the police were working for them and not against them,"

      This suggest to me that whatever evidence MSP discussed with them brought them hope. HOPE! Why would they have hope, unless MSP suggested they were looking at other things besides them.(them being the DiPietro's)?? Or even lack of evidence that Ayla is deceased.

      Some people will say that this was attorney spin. Maybe, maybe not. The DiPietro's could have had their attorney say that they had no comment about the meeting.

      So yes, I am serious.





      Delete
    6. You left out this part by Steve McClausand: "In January, McCausland said that Ayla's blood was found in the basement of her Violette Avenue home. Earlier this month, McCausland wouldn't respond directly to Bourget's statement but said "THERE HAS BEEN NO CHANGE IN ANY OF OUR PREVIOUS STATEMENTS." (Capitalized by me).

      Delete
    7. Trista complaining shows she's a complainer.
      As she has been from the start. Most of her interviews in fact are based on just that. More about herself than Ayla. "I just need to focus on me, I need closure", talking about her feelings about Justin or mad that SHE does not have answers. Not sad that she does not have her daughter or asking the person who has her to give her back. Trista's interviews do not show she cares. Trista complaining to LE does not show she cares it shows she is self centered and worried about herself.

      I am sure someone is going to jump on and say well at least she did interviews blah blah blah.. Justin did not.
      Only he did.

      So I will answer now. Sometimes less is definitely better.

      Delete
    8. You left out this part by Steve McClausand: "In January, McCausland said that Ayla's blood was found in the basement of her Violette Avenue home. Earlier this month, McCausland wouldn't respond directly to Bourget's statement but said "THERE HAS BEEN NO CHANGE IN ANY OF OUR PREVIOUS STATEMENTS." (Capitalized by me).
      _______________________________________________________

      That OBVIOUSLY refers to the blood. Now go look back and read McCausland's statements regarding blood. He has said a few things, the Reynolds clan has embellished. MCCAUSLAND'S statements about the blood could still be true. He said no amount, he said no location, and he said no cause for the blood being there.

      Delete
    9. Anon. 12/30 2:36,

      No Anon. I didn't leave anything out, perhaps you misunderstood my comment.
      My comment was not about what McCausland has stated, rather what the DiPietro family stated.
      First, the statement you quoted was not in the same article that I was quoting from.
      Second, I am aware of every statment that McCausland has made, and has not made, about Ayla's case.

      Delete
  2. I would not want to be on the side of hate when it comes to Trista. So far she has threatened to sue DHHS, called the father of her child an abuser and a murder (while at the same time saying she was sleeping with him),and now it appears MSP is on her bad side. Well to be precise I would say that started back when she petitioned the Governor because in Trista's words:

    "The Maine State Police in particular was called out by me, they and all the other organizations that have been involved are absolute heroes and they continue to do their best for Ayla. But I submit more needs to be done. Governor LePage, as former Mayor of Waterville I am sure you know how important it is for the community to be able to move on after a tragedy. I beseech you to speak to the investigators and the prosecutors on Ayla’s behalf, the sooner arrests can be made and justice served the sooner the community can move on."

    So that was when it started. Trista did not feel they were doing their job then and went over their heads back then.

    By the they way Governor Lepage's response was to politely say:

    "I trust the dedicated professionals who are involved in this investigation and must rely on their good judgment as they move forward."

    "Please understand that it would be inappropriate for me to publicly comment or issue an opinion in regards to an open and ongoing criminal investigation."

    When Trista is mad seems she lets people know it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I am mad I let people know it as well.

      Delete
    2. That does seem to be a common trait among Trista and her "friends".

      Delete
  3. Does anyone know if Justins first call was to 911 or Derek? Just asking as I never saw the response to this anywhere. Please if you are going to call me names keep it civil.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No Dana, there has been no reponse to Trista's claim by anyone, at least that I am aware of.

      Delete
    2. The only one I know of that claims this is Trista. MSP has neither confirmed nor denied. A good question is this, how does Trista know this if the cops aren't telling her anything? Yet she keeps dropping bombshells. I wonder if she consults the attorney about them beforehand?

      Delete
    3. @Dana

      I don't think there was a response to that anywhere.

      Delete
    4. Good point GRACE! Trista says for 6 months she hasn't gotten any info, there's been silence.

      So either she knew that all along, and just now decided to spill it---OR she's just making things up out of spite.

      Delete
    5. the space between12/30/12, 12:34 PM

      I have assumed (I don't think I've ever heard) that Justin would have called Phoebe first to see if she came home and took Ayla out somewhere before calling 911.

      What would be the point of calling Derek? If Justin knew in advance what happened to Ayla why call Derek? The people saying this believe Justin is guilty and some that Derek is involved. I fail to see how this "information" proves their thoughts about it. I haven't heard anything that makes me believe that Justin knew he was going to be calling 911 that morning.

      Delete
    6. Thanks for the replies It was something I had read and didn't know if it was fact or just something someone was thinking could have happened.

      Delete
  4. the space between12/30/12, 12:23 PM

    apparently Amanda and Trista have put their differences aside (picture 3)

    http://bangordailynews.com/slideshow/trista-reynolds-friends-and-family-mark-one-year-since-ayla-disappeared/

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm parsing from the December 16 issue of the Morning Sentinel. I'm sorry if these points have already been discussed here, but some of this is news to me:

    "The toddler's parents have endured the most scrutiny, some of it fueled by each against the other. He still blames her. She still suspects him.
    (WHEN DID JUSTIN EVER BLAME TRISTA?)

    Police confirmed that he bought a $25,000 life insurance policy against Ayla less than two months before she vanished. (I THOUHT MCCAUSLAND REFUSED TO COMMENT ON THE DETAILS OF THE CLIP.)

    Ayla's blood was found in the basement of the Waterville home. Police would not reveal how much, but said it was "more than a cupful." (WHAT??????? WHEN DID THE POLICE SAY "IT WAS MORE THAN A CUPFUL????)

    "I hate him so much, but then at the same time I want to, like, see him," she (Reynolds) said. "I feel like if I see him, I'm going to see Ayla because she's him." (I'M NOT GOING TO COMMENT ON THIS STATEMENT...)

    In the beginning, it was a missing persons case. Then, it was classified as an abduction. Then the foul play declaration. Now, it has once again been classified a missing persons case, the third unsolved missing child investigation in Maine in the last 40 years. (AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO DIDN'T GET THE MEMO THAT THIS CASE CHANGED FROM FOUL PLAY BACK TO A MISSING PERSONS?)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good work, I missed these. Thanks, kitty!

      Delete
  6. Just curious; What do most people posting here believe happened to Ayla? Not many people seem to have any really clear ideas. I realize that some suspect Trista of abducting Ayla and hiding her somewhere, and that Justin and his family have been unfairly maligned, but everyone (including LE) seems to be fairly unclear and muddled about just where she could be.

    One or two, here, believe that Justin and Trista are in a conspiracy together or could at least be locked in knowledge of her whereabouts. To accomplish what? I am unsure. Perhaps to share the LIP? It's such a small sum to split between the two parents who don't ever seem to be on the same page. A conspiracy to kill Ayla or hide her away seems a little off the wall for them. Maybe their continual disagreement is all an act and they are true consorts in crime.

    Does anyone believe that Justin's family together with the help of the Tudelas have hidden Ayla away to protect her from Trista? Many here seem to believe firmly that Ayla is alive and just has to be found.

    Have either family hired any outside help to find Ayla? If both families pooled their collective resources, could a private detective help find Ayla? Neither family seems to have been pro-active in finding Ayla, although Trista has the backing of a missing children's organization and does give interviews while Justin says his group has put up billboards in many states, but refuses to talk to the media because the media expoects him to trash Trista and he's not going do that tit-for-tat thing.

    Aside from either Justin and/or Trista being involved, does anyone here believe that Ayla's disappearance is due to a stranger abduction? In which case, I would presume, theories of her still being alive with a caring kidnapper are null and void as most children kidnapped for nefarious purposes are usually killed soon after.

    Yet. Justin, himself, seemed to say in one of his first press interviews, that he believed she was with someone who thought he/she could give Ayla a better life than with either of her parents. Most here believe, I think, that Justin is referring to relatives or friends of Trista. Trista, herself, seems unsure of what happened to her daughter and alternately believes Justin is behind Ayla's disappearance, knows what happened to her, or failed to protect Ayla.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have always had the theory that one or the other have hid Ayla away. Possibly to someone who will give her a good home and raise her as their own. If the latter then it is possible there was an exchange of money. I do not think you will see Ayla reunited with either parent in the latter case unless someone caves in and admits to what they have done. I don't think there will be a body recovered if there was fear of that someone would have caved already. This is just my opinion and I prefer this to someone killing a defenseless child in a fit of rage.I would like to think both parents love Ayla to much to see her come to any harm.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't have a theory as to what happened to Ayla per se, but I do feel she very well could have been abducted.

      What I do NOT believe is that 3, 4, or more people are involved in a conspiracy to cover up a murder, accidental death, and/or disposal of Ayla.

      What I will NOT do is accuse someone and/or others of harming or disposing of Ayla, nor will I assume such, without the FACTS that prove to "me" that such occured.

      I do firmly feel that Ayla is alive, but can't explain that feeling.

      Delete
  8. Dana B. I see your point about choosing to believe Ayla is alive rather than dead, but is it a realistic view of the situation? What cases would be solved if LE, for example, investigated only in what they WANTED to believe happened to Ayla? Would any justice for Ayla or for her parents be served in adhereing to that belief system?

    In other words, it makes you personally happier to believe Ayla is alive rather than dead. So... what? You are agreeable to letting the situation just lie in the wishful-thinking mode? What if Ayla were your child? What if Ayla is alive and not being treated well, but abused?

    Also, it's a crime to steal a child should we just go with pie-in-the-sky feelings and let a crime of this magnitude go unpunished? Doesn't the lack of justice for such a crime engender more of the same? Do you feel that it is more important for you to have happy feelings about Ayla rather than to find her and punish whoever committed this crime?

    Not trying to be sarcastic, because I do understand thinking of Ayla alive and happy is more positive than the alternative thoughts, but how does that feeling get the job done? A child is missing and both sets of families are under suspicion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No we should go with facts and we have none that prove death so she very well could be alive.Is it realistic to only look for a dead Ayla? Are they even looking for an alive Ayla? They should check every possibility completely. LE said at one point they do not believe she is alive, but have not given any proof.Before I will say Ayla is not alive I want proof. The things that have been stated about abuse again more reason for a parent to seek someone that can raise Ayla without abusing her.You miss my point completely, is it easier to say one parent murdered Ayla or one parent gave her up to a better life? What is important is getting to the facts and truth. Accusations without proof do no good does it make you feel good to make them without it. How does constantly accusing someone of murder by rage get any results? They have been saying it for a year has it gotten justice for Ayla. Like I said the people that should have been there in the beginning for Ayla were most definitely not there. It doesn't mean they didn't love her, they were just not watching like they should have been. A parent that does drugs is just as guilty of abuse as one that hits a child. Mental abuse is just as wrong as physical abuse. Playing games with a child's life to get what you want is wrong.I need to give Ayla a chance at being alive even though I know she may not be.

      Delete
    2. the space between12/31/12, 11:32 PM

      well-written anon - although, did LE investigate all possibilities from the beginning? Justin reported that Ayla was abducted, and perhaps that he suspected Trista. Within the first hour, LE finds out she's on the road and doesn't pull the car over or search it? They only have 20 minutes of questioning for Fortier?

      As for Dana, ultimately it doesn't matter to the investigators what he believes. It doesn't matter what any of us believe. I don't know what happened. Until LE tells us definitively what happened, I will hope for the best. For my own sake, I keep an open mind. Hopefully the people that matter to the investigation do as well. I'm not sure how close-mindedness solves any crimes. I believe they should be looking for her alive also.

      Delete
  9. They probably quit telling Trista anything because she goes & tells someone over ther & they post it. I don't think Trista had anything to do with Ayla's disappearance but she does tell someone anything LE says & they go & post it so..............that's what I'm thinking.

    ReplyDelete
  10. cristine February 22, 2012 4:57 PM
    Ha- I had a black eye and 3 bruises on my face from my one year old last week! :) He has bruises and a tooth mark from slamming his forehead into my teeth! It happens...broken arm...happens...missing an appointment? Shameful








    ReplyDelete

ALL comments subject to removal. MODERATION becomes necessary when ignorance shows up. Don't be that person!